Senior Partner & Managing Director
The 2014 Consumer Value Creators Series
Over the past five years, the consumer nondurables (also known as fast-moving consumer goods) sector has delivered strong value creation for investors through a combination of top-line growth, higher margins, stronger valuation multiples, and smart financial strategies.
In 2014, as in past years, The Boston Consulting Group conducted an annual study of total shareholder return among 1,620 publicly traded companies in 26 industry sectors, of which 88 were in the nondurables sector.1 (For the complete analysis of all industry sectors, see Turnaround: Transforming Value Creation, the 2014 BCG Value Creators report, July 2014.) Overall, from 2009 through 2013, the nondurables companies in our sample returned an annualized TSR of 21 percent. Nondurables ranked fourth among the five groups of consumer companies studied—fashion and luxury, consumer durables, retail, and travel and tourism were the other four—and twelfth among all 26 industry sectors. (For an overview of the performance of the five consumer sectors, see “Rising Volatility, Growing Opportunity,” the BCG 2014 Consumer Value Creators Series, December 2014.)
The top ten nondurables companies returned 39 percent a year to shareholders from 2009 through 2013, an extremely strong performance by historical standards. However, the returns of both the overall sample and the top ten performers lagged those of other consumer sectors during the same period. In part, this may be owing to investors’ perception of nondurables companies as defensive investments. That perception helped buoy the sector during the recession, while companies in more cyclical sectors like durables and travel and tourism fell out of favor among investors. But those other sectors also benefited from much larger changes in valuation multiples over the past five years as they returned to favor.
The overall nondurables sector also had a smaller variation in TSR performance from top to bottom compared with the other consumer sectors. The best performer overall (Inner Mongolia Yili Industrial Group, a food manufacturer in China) returned an annual average of 58 percent to shareholders over the five-year period studied. However, the median company in the group (Brown-Forman) returned 21 percent a year, and the return of the company that came in fiftieth (Diageo) was 20 percent a year.
We broke down the top-performing nondurables companies into two groups: the overall global top ten and the top ten in developed markets only. (See Exhibits 1 and 2.) The theme common to both sets of top performers was the importance of growth, which accounted for a significant portion of shareholder value creation for the top ten companies on the global list and only slightly less for the top ten in developed markets. The takeaway is clear: growth—whether from new-product development, breakthrough innovation, leveraging and extending strong brands, exposure to high-growth markets, or selective M&A—is imperative for top-tier value creation among nondurables companies.
Not surprisingly, for emerging-market companies in particular—such as Mexico’s Arca Continental (fifth on the list of the global top ten) and India’s ITC (eighth)—top-line growth was the dominant contributor to value creation. These companies are establishing strong positions in rapidly expanding markets, and they are riding the wave of a rising middle class and its growing demand for nondurable goods. In developed markets, companies that derived much of their returns from top-line growth are leveraging breakthrough innovation to reshape a category, as Keurig Green Mountain (first among the top ten in developed markets and second globally) has done for packaged coffee.
Companies that did not benefit from such advantages paired their more moderate growth with improved margins. For example, every one of the top ten companies in developed markets expanded their margins (by about 9 percentage points in TSR contribution, on average). Of course, this was a more important factor in the total return of some companies than of others. Several developed-market winners used strong cost controls to buy inputs at lower prices and reduce overhead costs. In addition, many are leveraging brands and product innovation to realize higher price points, which also aids in boosting profit margins.
Developed-market winners generated significant cash flow that they were able to return to investors. In previous years, many focused on raising dividends. Now, however, the focus has shifted to repayment of debt, which made a larger contribution to TSR during the five-year period analyzed than changes in either dividend yield or number of shares. Roughly one-third of the total TSR delivered by the top ten companies in developed markets came from changes in capital allocation.
Analysis of the top ten performers both globally and in developed markets suggests four value-creation models for consumer nondurables companies.
Despite these opportunities, there are some clear pitfalls for companies in the consumer nondurables sector. These include chasing growth that erodes margins, cutting costs in a way that undermines the growth agenda, and pursuing aggressive M&A in which the company buys or overpays for assets that do not fit into its existing portfolio.
Although the global economy is recovering and consumer confidence is rising, the near term is highly uncertain, given tepid growth in the U.S., a slowdown in China, the recession in Japan, and a predeflationary environment in Europe, among other challenges. Nonetheless, there are pockets of opportunity for consumer nondurables companies. Fundamentally, growth remains the primary imperative for driving shareholder value, and the right growth model depends very much on context. Both market opportunity and the ability to differentiate offerings from those of competitors will shape a company’s potential growth trajectory. For many, the path to value creation will also require continued improvement to margins through pricing, cost control, or both. Choosing the right approach for a company’s particular situation, setting expectations clearly with investors, and executing in a disciplined manner will yield handsome returns.