Managing Director & Senior Partner
Related Expertise: Procurement
Chief procurement officers must balance two equally important imperatives: they need to adopt digital procurement technologies even as they sustain traditional procurement methods. Both digital and traditional procurement will be sources of significant value. These were the principal issues discussed at the 11th European Procurement Roundtable, which we hosted in Amsterdam in October 2017. More than 80 CPOs and senior procurement executives attended, representing companies whose annual spending totals €770 billion. Our theme, “Pushing the Value Envelope,” captures the challenge faced by those who must keep a foot in the world of traditional value drivers while pushing forward into the new digital world.
Among our guest speakers were Gordon von Bretten, managing director at KKR Capstone, proclaiming: “Strategic sourcing, including technical and demand levers, is alive and kicking but requires a strong executive mandate to drive out cost.” Guest speaker Vivienne Bracken, CPO at National Grid, joined us too and stated: “The procurement function is growing in its reputation as a commercial function that can add real-time value to National Grid’s businesses by developing deep category knowledge.”
Following are summaries of just some of our in-depth discussions.
Digital is no longer only a buzzword in procurement. It is now a call to action. Of 30 companies listed on the German DAX, 29 mention digital as a focus in their annual report and 17 particularly cite digital innovation of the procurement core as a field for the future. Of course, some digital applications are already underway in procurement. In operational procurement, for example, robots and automated solutions such as touchless purchase order approvals are changing the landscape, with an expected 30% workforce reduction in the medium term.
In strategic procurement, CPOs are focused on how to generate meaningful data from systems inside and outside their departments and how, based on these data sets, to generate insights that go beyond what is possible today and that will guide their strategic choices. This includes gathering tail spend data to prepare for focused tail tenders as well as monitoring strategic suppliers’ internal cost curves to keep their margins in check.
The CPOs concluded that the first thing to do when making choices concerning digital tools is to consider their own strategic priorities, be they savings, innovation, speed, or risk avoidance. They should focus on tools that directly support these priorities, rather than choosing solutions simply because they are in fashion.
Plan now for the digital supply chains of the future. These supply chains need to be understood from the perspective of the end customers’ demand. Becoming best in class with respect to demand forecasting will have a massive impact on all upstream activities, including procurement.
We demonstrated and discussed important technologies in the advanced planning space, such as artificial-intelligence-based forecasting procedures. It’s important for CPOs to get familiar with these technologies: according to a recent study, about 60% of companies are not yet using AI to harness the analytics power it can potentially deliver. However, 90% of the CPOs in attendance indicated that their companies are planning dramatic changes in their supply chain management.
Overall, the participants felt, it is mandatory to take prompt action in the field of supply chain management because digital will be the new standard in a few years. Companies must adapt to new digital ways of working. We know that leading companies today are already doing so.
Take heed of Industry 4.0. It’s crucial, CPOs say, to look at developments in procurement and supply chain management not narrowly but widely, with an understanding of how digital changes in other functions have implications on their work. Industry 4.0, the latest phase of the industrial revolution, was identified as a critical area because it describes the changes occurring among functions that are core business partners for procurement.
The technologies that make up Industry 4.0 will influence procurement in two ways:
We discussed a number of well-established procurement levers, including zero-based budgeting (ZBB), commodity sourcing, and “should costing,” which are still driving large shares of value.
ZBB will allow companies to remain lean in the long term. ZBB is a cost philosophy that introduces a new way of working based on a rigorous bottom-up budgeting process and clear cost accountability. The objective: to rigorously reset the cost basis of an organization and ensure that it is kept lean on a long-term basis. Typically, it results in reductions of SG&A costs of up to 30%, and its sustainability is embedded through a set of new roles, responsibilities, and processes. ZBB goes beyond planning a zero-based budget. It introduces clear, zero-based accountabilities.
Take a look at commodity sourcing. Commoditization continues to increase. Once products and goods have reached a certain level of commoditization, the trend is unlikely to reverse naturally. More and more companies are buying commodities and are thus subject to commodity-related challenges such as price risk, scarcity, and the need for transparency.
Additionally, supply markets have become increasingly competitive. Merchants and distributors, given their size and integration along the value chain, have built strong market positions. But emerging commodity platforms and expanding exchanges offer additional sourcing opportunities and routes to market. Most players will need to adapt their commodity strategy and supporting operational platform. While they do not need to transform into classical traders, they should embed critical trading, optimization, and risk management capabilities to build a competitive edge and master the challenges ahead.
“Should cost” modeling is a game changer. In times of new technologies, shorter product life cycles, and continued cost pressure, the case for product cost optimization is stronger than ever. Experienced practitioners and beginners both need to realize next-level product cost savings. Should-cost modeling works best when built on a strong fact base, which allows for eye-opening insights and strong arguments for more cost-efficient solutions. In fact, should-cost modeling can also be a powerful tool to wield during negotiations.
Two main conclusions were reached in this discussion: companies should not be complacent—premium brands and higher-margin manufacturers can be cost leaders too. And should-cost modeling capabilities are a game-changer and prerequisite for continuous product cost optimization.
There are ways to set up BPO deals for success. In negotiating big business-process-outsourcing (BPO) deals, five factors help to ensure success:
Of course, trust and transparency remain the key prerequisites for a successful long-term BPO partnership.
Take a fresh look at how to manage indirect spending. CPOs from across industries strive to add value but struggle to gain the support of business and functional stakeholders for those efforts. In many organizations, delivering value through indirect spending management is met with resistance.
CPOs need to step outside the traditional procurement view and look at issues from the perspective of stakeholders, including the CEO. Procurement needs to move beyond just cost-cutting and take a more differentiated business view in order to really belong to the core of the company. Procurement functions should adapt to fill very different roles, those of strategic partner, strategic enabler, risk owner, or efficiency driver, depending on the risk and impact involved. CPOs who seek to step up and deliver strategic competitive advantage, beyond cost savings, should ensure that the procurement function includes skills in business development, risk insight, and stakeholder management.
Revisiting the engaging and inspiring discussions from our October 2017 roundtable is a good way to launch into the new year. We look forward to more conversations—and a chance to convene with you again at the 2018 roundtable.
ABOUT BOSTON CONSULTING GROUP
Boston Consulting Group partners with leaders in business and society to tackle their most important challenges and capture their greatest opportunities. BCG was the pioneer in business strategy when it was founded in 1963. Today, we work closely with clients to embrace a transformational approach aimed at benefiting all stakeholders—empowering organizations to grow, build sustainable competitive advantage, and drive positive societal impact.
Our diverse, global teams bring deep industry and functional expertise and a range of perspectives that question the status quo and spark change. BCG delivers solutions through leading-edge management consulting, technology and design, and corporate and digital ventures. We work in a uniquely collaborative model across the firm and throughout all levels of the client organization, fueled by the goal of helping our clients thrive and enabling them to make the world a better place.
© Boston Consulting Group 2024. All rights reserved.
For information or permission to reprint, please contact BCG at firstname.lastname@example.org. To find the latest BCG content and register to receive e-alerts on this topic or others, please visit bcg.com. Follow Boston Consulting Group on Facebook and X (formerly Twitter).