Most technology leaders at large enterprises have answered the question, “Should I move to the cloud?” with a resounding “Yes.” The result is a $100 billion market that is growing at a rate of more than 25% per year. Cloud architecture is at the center of most companies’ innovation and digital agendas.
But the question of moving to the cloud is only the first of many, and further questions get complicated fast. Today’s heterogeneous infrastructure environments demand that CIOs decide on which capabilities to move now, which to move down the road (and why and when), which to keep on premises, and which cloud (or more often, clouds) to use. All these decisions must be made while ensuring that multiple cloud and legacy environments work together in a seamless manner. (See “Cloud Definitions.”)
In this fast-growing market, clarity on what constitutes an efficient and effective multicloud approach is hard to come by. One reason is that companies have followed multiple paths to mainstream adoption. Some intentionally embrace multicloud as a strategic C-suite decision. Others land there through M&A or were guided by developers, software vendors, and disparate decision makers from business units, skunkworks teams, and central IT. Regardless of route, most are now calling it a strategy—even as they struggle to make the best of what is often a multicloud muddle.
This article presents a framework to help companies navigate a complex multicloud landscape effectively. We examine key questions on how they can bring a true strategic lens to decision making and offer ideas on how to thrive on the multicloud frontier.
A CLOUD-FILLED FORECAST
While experts often talk about a migration to the cloud, in reality, we are in the midst of a stampede. Based on recent interviews with more than 250 CIOs, CTOs, lead cloud engineers, and other key cloud decision makers, it appears that almost 95% of enterprises are already in hybrid environments, with about two-thirds of large businesses using multiple public cloud providers. (See Exhibit 1.)
All categories of workloads—core business apps, transaction systems, customer-facing apps, and data and analytics capabilities—are becoming enabled by the cloud. Enterprise spending on public and private cloud computing is expected to double in the next two to three years, with the fastest growth taking place on public clouds. This is due, in part, to the fact that most companies are deliberately diversifying their cloud providers. It is common for larger companies to use up to four cloud platforms, both public and private, for different functions and applications.
This kind of multicloud approach delivers multiple benefits, including increased agility, flexibility, innovation rates, and the ability to deploy cutting-edge technology and platform strengths. It also surfaces new types of concern. Global companies need to think through how using a cloud platform in one country or region could affect operations or sales in another. Selecting best-in-class offerings for each workload is a clear priority, and so is avoiding vendor lock-in. As one executive said, “We just won't put all our eggs in one basket. There is a high probability that many providers will be in the mix in three to five years.” More regulators are looking for companies to apply a multicloud strategy. Costs, of course, are a big factor, and having a multicloud strategy increases negotiating leverage. One CIO put it this way: “My goal is to get everything to the cloud and save a lot of money doing it.”
LOST IN THE CLOUD?
As a result of increased multicloud usage, both heterogeneity and interdependencies are rising rapidly. Complexity is exploding. Across industries, enterprise CIOs are encountering new, unanticipated pain points, including:
Most enterprises say they are not well-prepared for these challenges, with more than half of the executives we interviewed pointing to new risks, complexity, and uncertainty as major issues. Yet, the march toward a multicloud approach continues unabated. “All global companies are going to need to be multicloud,” a telecom executive told us. “It's an absolute necessity going forward.” A media company executive said, “No one cloud is best at everything. If you're not multicloud, you're not getting the most out of your technology.”
The question for enterprises is how to effectively and efficiently navigate a multicloud approach.
FINDING AN EFFICIENT MULTICLOUD MODEL
The choice of a multicloud model is often based on the tradeoff between two competing needs: maximizing use case flexibility and controlling chaos through architectural constraints.
Use Case Flexibility. The ability to solve complex or multiple use cases by leveraging the strengths of different clouds is a critical determinant of multicloud strategy because companies want a best-in-class environment in each context. For example, a movie theater operator chose to run its high data-volume media analytics on Google’s BigQuery, ticket processing on IBM’s Z Cloud, and customer-facing applications on AWS. The company could have simplified its technology landscape by accepting lower performance in some of these areas but only at the cost of weaker insights, longer lines, or higher expenses. Other companies with narrowly focused use cases or clear priorities for best-in-class solutions may choose to adopt a single cloud for their priority use case and accept lower performance in other parts of the business.
Architectural Constraints and Standardization. When building applications across multiple clouds, technology teams need standardization to scale engineering and development processes as well as to control risk. In addition, these teams often face architectural constraints imposed internally (by a leadership team that prioritizes risk reduction and control, for example) or by regulators—and more often, the latter. For example, a global retailer might be required to have data centers in multiple regions because of GDPR and data-sovereignty requirements, or a financial institution may be required to run pricing-related workloads in a private cloud environment due to government security requirements (such as multistep authentication and multiple firewalls).
A View of the Frontier. A spectrum of cloud adoption models emerges based on these competing dimensions. (See Exhibit 2.)
Of course, every company has its own situation and needs, but the “efficient multicloud frontier” comprises three approaches. These approaches balance flexibility, innovation, and the ability to satisfy multiple complex and dynamic use cases against transparency, control, and value maximization across various environments. (See Exhibit 3.) The problem is that executives at many different types of enterprises indicate that they—and very likely their peers—remain outside (usually below, but occasionally above) the efficient frontier in terms of the cloud model they have adopted.
Understanding where your organization sits today in relation to this frontier, and how to move closer to an efficient solution, is key to developing an effective multicloud strategy. In our experience, however, while the first three positions can all be efficient depending on a company’s profile, companies successfully occupying positions one and three are rare. For position one, the company must strategically determine that the rate of innovation is more important than the value gained from integration and that the risks of unconstrained development do not pose a business threat to the organization. For position three, priority use cases must be narrowly circumscribed, with innovation taking a back seat to management simplicity and control. Our interviews suggest that a significant majority of enterprises will ideally operate in the “balanced” multicloud model (position two), which balances the delivery of a variety of use cases against some level of architectural constraints. (See “Kroger’s Multicloud Journey.”)
IMPLEMENTING THE RIGHT MULTICLOUD MODEL
Multicloud is not the answer for everyone. Companies should let their strategies and use cases guide their technology decisions and cloud approach. Striking the right balance between control and innovation can be tough for multicloud users. In our experience, there are five key elements to getting the balance right. (See Exhibit 4.)
The choice of partners to help with the journey is also critical. Enterprises need to be pragmatic and unreserved about putting out requests for information and systematically engaging different partners along the cloud journey, from strategizing to piloting to scaling. This is not only important for shaping greenfield cloud migrations but also for rebooting existing migrations and cloud transformations that are failing to achieve intended results.
Advisory firms can help frame the right strategy and business case. They are instrumental to planning and reprioritization. Reengaging cloud vendors and infrastructure software vendors—and understanding their go-forward roadmaps—can help shape the decision to build versus buy. The overriding importance and fluid nature of security means companies need the latest capabilities. Infrastructure software vendors specialize in a number of services, including those related to security (such as access, identity governance, and intelligence and operations); multicloud DevSecOps (especially monitoring, log aggregation, and orchestration); and governance, risk management, and compliance.
System integrators—which offer a range of services related to technology, gap analysis, and security—are critical in helping bridge the talent gap and can reduce the risk inherent in migration and scaling. Integrators also offer managed services, particularly for security and networking, as well as assistance with training and organizational enablement.
For their part, cloud service providers can invest in becoming the top choice for individual workloads, expand their capabilities by workload, and augment current offerings to address major pain points, including legacy software modernization and interoperability with cloud-native services. They can also look for ways to position current middleware and platform offerings to address multicloud use cases while supporting the modernization of legacy applications.
While a multicloud strategy has become an enterprise norm, it is far from a one-size-fits-all solution. Many companies thrive with it, but for others, single-cloud architecture is still the most logical approach. The choice of architecture needs to be driven by priorities and start from the point of view that less is often more.
For companies that choose to go the multicloud route, scaling the operating model becomes critical, and they must often systematically invest in multiple capabilities—in addition to technology—to ensure success. The two questions most CIOs should ask today: “Is my digital transformation agenda supported by the right cloud architecture? Can pragmatic process and platform choices lead to a better position on the efficient multicloud frontier?”
ABOUT BOSTON CONSULTING GROUP
Boston Consulting Group partners with leaders in business and society to tackle their most important challenges and capture their greatest opportunities. BCG was the pioneer in business strategy when it was founded in 1963. Today, we work closely with clients to embrace a transformational approach aimed at benefiting all stakeholders—empowering organizations to grow, build sustainable competitive advantage, and drive positive societal impact.
Our diverse, global teams bring deep industry and functional expertise and a range of perspectives that question the status quo and spark change. BCG delivers solutions through leading-edge management consulting, technology and design, and corporate and digital ventures. We work in a uniquely collaborative model across the firm and throughout all levels of the client organization, fueled by the goal of helping our clients thrive and enabling them to make the world a better place.
© Boston Consulting Group 2023. All rights reserved.
For information or permission to reprint, please contact BCG at email@example.com. To find the latest BCG content and register to receive e-alerts on this topic or others, please visit bcg.com. Follow Boston Consulting Group on Facebook and X (formerly Twitter).