There can be a huge difference in the digital experience offered by different retail banks. To understand how big, let’s look over the shoulders of two customers, Zuzanna and Oliver, as they use their mobile-banking apps.
It’s 10 a.m. in Warsaw, and with a few quick taps on her phone, Zuzanna is repaying a friend for last night’s dinner. As she sends the money, Zuzanna sees a reminder to activate her new credit card. The bank will give her 5% cash back if she uses her card five times in the coming week, and it’s offering a discount at her regular coffee shop if she uses her card to pay there. She taps the “activate” button, which automatically loads the card digitally into her e-wallet, orders herself a discounted coffee, and heads out for the day. The convenience and speed of this and other mobile-banking experiences have turned Zuzanna into something close to a purely digital customer; she rarely steps into a branch office anymore.
In another European city, Oliver is having a different experience. While attempting to open a new savings account, he gets frustrated when the application form in the banking app doesn’t prefill with his profile information. This means he has to provide—yet again—data that he’s given to the bank many times before. He gets stuck somewhere in the middle of the process and is forced to go to his local branch to complete the application.
For banks, digital sales are a crucial new benchmark—and a logical next step in the race to digitization. For every one time that customers visit a branch, they now access their banking apps between 50 and 80 times. And this doesn’t take into account visits to bank websites, which make the ratio of digital to physical interactions even more lopsided. Yet despite this mammoth behavioral shift, most banks’ proportion of digital sales hasn’t increased by much. It remains an opportunity that banks haven’t seized.
In their next phase of hiring, technology buying, and strategy formulation, banks need to create a foundation for digital sales. The ones that do so will gain a lasting advantage.
To determine the extent to which customers are willing and able to buy bank products digitally (by using a bank’s mobile app or online site, rather than by visiting a branch), we sat down with actual customers of more than 140 banks globally—our “mystery shoppers”—while they worked with more than 210 sales-related features on their digital-banking apps and websites. We looked at the following features and scored their effectiveness:
Not many banks are doing a good job in all these areas simultaneously. In observing our mystery shoppers, we found that very few banks are delivering personalized marketing to their customers’ mobile devices. (The Polish bank used by Zuzanna is the rare exception.) Many banks provide product information over their digital channels, but the presentation often doesn’t take advantage of the medium’s interactivity or, in the case of mobile, is not suited to the small screen. It’s almost never easy to buy a bank product digitally; most such attempts result in the shopper’s having to re-enter personal data, be redirected to a separate bank website, or visit a branch. And heaven help the shopper who wants support while making a purchase: the options, whether phone, chat, or video, are usually rudimentary—if they are available at all.
As a result, most of the banks we looked at score low on our digital-sales diagnostic; the median score of the banks’ mobile apps is 22 out of 100. This is a stunningly low number given the billions of dollars that banks collectively have poured into their digital initiatives in recent years.
Of course, not every bank performs badly. At the more advanced end of the continuum, some banks in Poland and Spain have scores up to three times the global average. (See Exhibit 1.) While we have not yet compared banks’ digital scores with their actual digital sales—which we estimate at 10% to 15% of total sales at banks globally—there is plenty of empirical evidence that the two move in tandem.
Performing well in the categories described above isn’t solely a function of a bank’s excelling at data and analytics—there’s much more to it than that. In our view, most banks are going to have to rethink their digital-sales “stacks”: the technology, processes, talent, operating model, and coordinating mechanisms needed to increase sales through digital channels. (See Exhibit 2.)
At banks, the stack has five distinct layers, most of them requiring new capabilities and infrastructure:
Each layer of the digital stack comes with its own technology set, business processes, and organizational imperatives. At the best banks, these are set up and orchestrated in much the same way as at a digitally native company. And the method of achieving outcomes is similar, too. Just as Amazon seamlessly fulfills orders and Google stimulates consumer demand by ensuring that its messages are relevant, best-practice banks do the same.
To understand the challenges, let’s look at what a single layer—marketing operations—might be trying to accomplish at a given point in time. We’ll use just one campaign as an example: an effort to get customers to increase their savings balances.
Such a campaign is relatively common, and it makes sense to pursue it digitally as well as through traditional marketing. In managing the digital parts of a savings account campaign, however, most banks don’t make effective use of marketing operations. Common mistakes include underestimating the scale and breadth of the required effort or assuming that it can be handled by old-school CRM systems originally built to support branches or contact centers. Sometimes banks allow different teams to create their own messages, using systems that overlap and are poorly coordinated. And then there are the structural pitfalls, such as when a marketing operations team sits in the wrong place in an organization or doesn’t have the decision rights it needs.
At a bank with a more effective approach to digital, marketing operations would be very selective about the customer IDs it targets for the savings campaign. And it would pick a marketing approach that makes sense for each individual prospect, based on a unique combination of customer preferences and behaviors. For example, the notification would say “Hello Zuzanna” if Zuzanna had indicated that she prefers that greeting to the more formal “Good afternoon, Ms. Kowalski.” And if the bank knows that Zuzanna tends to do some mobile banking on her commute to work, it might display the campaign message at 8 a.m. on a weekday morning on the mobile app. Or suppose Zuzanna has deposited 10,000 zlotys from a fixed-term investment that has just matured at a competitor bank; in that case, the bank might offer her a special bonus savings rate to dissuade her from reinvesting the funds at the other bank.
Of course, a single campaign such as this can only provide a partial picture of what the marketing operations layer does. The real challenge is coordinating the execution of hundreds of campaigns, which necessitates selecting from among dozens of formats and managing multiple channels and millions of communications each day.
The payoff from having a well-developed digital-sales stack isn’t just the increase in digital sales. A bank that has built up its digital operations in this way will reap other benefits as well, including an increase in digital traffic and a reduction in costs. (See Exhibit 3.)
For many banks, it helps to start with a self-assessment: Where are we today for each of our main offerings in the market? Where are we lagging and why? Do the gaps matter, given our strategic priorities? What is our current level of digital sales? What would we like it to be two years from now? Do we have a mobile app with features our customers love to use? How well-developed are the different layers of our digital-sales stack?
Data and analytics isn’t the only capability that banks need in order to sell more through their digital channels. All five layers of the stack are important. The good news is that it’s possible, indeed advisable for most banks, to develop the digital stack incrementally. Fortunately, there are several viable paths to become best in class in digital sales. The right approach depends on your own bank’s strategy, customer base, and technology roadmap.
Begin with some no-regrets steps. Identify your strategic priorities as a bank: what needs you wish to serve, what products you have to meet those needs, which market shares you want to grow, and which customer segments to target. Then optimize your existing stack. Put people who are experienced in delivering digital campaigns in key roles, deliver campaigns more quickly, and improve governance.
Next, turn your attention to deeper improvements. Build the analytics engine and use it to drive digital traffic along the sales funnel. Start with one customer segment and a simple high-volume product, one distribution channel and messaging format. Build what you need, and quickly learn and scale from there. Over time, add customer segments and products, and build out the stack. In our work, we have seen programs start delivering end-to-end capabilities in six to nine months. It doesn’t need to take years.
Your efforts to increase digital sales will have the best chance of succeeding if they are part of a broader digitization strategy—that is, if you are also building capabilities and skills to support a dramatically improved customer experience. In addition, your digital development needs to focus on customer advocacy and the structural lowering of costs. And it helps if you have an ongoing program to explore new tech-led business models and revenue streams, including revenue streams outside of your core business.
But their low levels of digital sales mean that most banks should make it a priority—all on its own—to increase their readiness to sell more products digitally. Remember that with every passing day, your customers’ expectations of a great digital experience are increasing. And as in any race, you can’t win if you haven’t even qualified to compete.
ABOUT BOSTON CONSULTING GROUP
Boston Consulting Group partners with leaders in business and society to tackle their most important challenges and capture their greatest opportunities. BCG was the pioneer in business strategy when it was founded in 1963. Today, we work closely with clients to embrace a transformational approach aimed at benefiting all stakeholders—empowering organizations to grow, build sustainable competitive advantage, and drive positive societal impact.
Our diverse, global teams bring deep industry and functional expertise and a range of perspectives that question the status quo and spark change. BCG delivers solutions through leading-edge management consulting, technology and design, and corporate and digital ventures. We work in a uniquely collaborative model across the firm and throughout all levels of the client organization, fueled by the goal of helping our clients thrive and enabling them to make the world a better place.
© Boston Consulting Group 2023. All rights reserved.
For information or permission to reprint, please contact BCG at firstname.lastname@example.org. To find the latest BCG content and register to receive e-alerts on this topic or others, please visit bcg.com. Follow Boston Consulting Group on Facebook and X (formerly Twitter).