Not long ago, a small contingent from a company’s change management office was dispatched to a remote field operation. The purpose of the trip was to ensure the adoption of new digital processes. The meeting was not a success. The field managers—many with decades of experience in their disciplines—didn’t like the new processes and didn’t see why they should adopt them. The change management team returned to headquarters fearing the resistance they had encountered would derail the program. It still may.
Companies that want to endure must be skilled at transformation. There are a lot of reasons why so many of the companies that were on the Fortune 500 list 25 years ago have disappeared from it. However, one common thread is a failure to adapt. Often the failure isn’t a matter of vision but of execution. An effective approach to change management is especially important today; the coronavirus pandemic is testing the adaptive skills of every organization.
Mistakes in change management follow a few familiar patterns. Some companies form their change management units for specific projects at the last minute and do not clarify the role that they expect the change management team to play. Other companies focus primarily on the communication plan and don’t take the time to think through the impact that a set of new behaviors will have on their organizations.
Still other companies outsource their change management functions, or staff them with relatively junior people. In some cases, the change management team institutes operational changes directly—with the best of intentions—but doesn’t secure a department’s buy-in. The changes feel “bolted on” and don’t last.
Over the course of hundreds of client transformations, Boston Consulting Group has identified ways to minimize these problems—and strengthen companies’ change management functions.
Three actions are crucial:
The life cycle of a typical transformation comprises four phases: a goal-setting phase; a baseline and target phase (for determining where the organization is and where it needs to end up); a solution and capability development phase; and an implementation and sustained improvement phase. The role and composition of the change management function should evolve from phase to phase.
Let’s take a hypothetical example of a multibillion-dollar company that has decided to remove costs throughout its global operations. In the goal-setting phase, the change management team functions as a strategic partner. This begins with getting a clear picture of the magnitude of the reductions.
Because this is a high-level strategy discussion—usually involving the CEO and the CFO—the change management team should be more senior and relatively small. A big part of the change management team’s job in this phase is to clarify unit leaders’ roles in the transformation and start to equip those leaders for the journey to come. This includes defining the change management method and approach—whether developed internally or with the help of external partners—and describing the tools that the organization will employ.
The strategic partner role continues into the baseline and target phase, when more specific goals are set. (See Exhibit 1.) For instance, the company may have decided it must lower its overall costs by 20% and may have made some initial decisions about the cuts that will come from individual business units, functions, and geographical locations. The change management team’s job is to anticipate the organization’s response to these high-level goals and come up with a plan that addresses the challenges and increases the odds of a smooth transition.
For the solution and capability development phase, the change management team’s role becomes one of enablement. This is when many of the most challenging transformation activities take place, including engaging employees, encouraging them to cocreate solutions, identifying and addressing areas of resistance, and getting people to adopt new ways of working. This is also the time when training curricula are put together and when KPIs and scorecards start to be used in tracking progress.
In this phase of a transformation, the change team’s span of influence needs to expand beyond the executives and leaders it focused on previously. Its influence now touches the entire organization. For this to work, the change management function generally needs to grow in size and become embedded in individual businesses and functions. The change management staffers who work in these local hubs need not be as senior as those who participated in the initial strategy phases. But the staffers do need to be conversant with the change agenda and tools, skilled at training and coaching, and knowledgeable about the business areas they are helping.
In the final phase—implementation and sustained improvement—the change management function assumes the role of a guardian. Its job is to make sure that the individual departments continue to use the new tools, practices, and work approaches that were put in place, and to set up the measurement systems that will guard against backsliding. The local change management hubs start to shrink at this point and may even disband once the changes become ingrained with workers.
The evolving role that change management takes can help companies minimize the people challenges that routinely crop up in transformations. But for some other challenges—like keeping track of the multitude of moving parts—some key traits are needed. We find that the following traits are always present in a good change management function:
Transformation programs have any number of objectives—examples include digitizing back-office operations, implementing new technology systems, integrating sales forces with an acquired company, and improving innovation performance. Indeed, at a big company, many transformation efforts could be underway simultaneously.
Four basic organizational structures for change management have emerged. (See Exhibit 2.) The structure that a company adopts may reflect its sense of how frequently it’s going to need to transform. Or it could reflect a company-wide bias toward centralization or decentralization.
The four structural options are as follows:
Companies usually default to project-specific change management when they’re first doing transformations. Formal enterprise change management, with centralized resources, often comes next, when companies have multiple transformations in the pipeline and are seeking to build out a permanent change management capability.
However, companies with the most experience doing transformations often distribute their change management function, placing their change management people in the locations and business units where the transformations are happening. Arguably the most sophisticated distributed structure is the hybrid type, which has both a central brain trust to offer high-level guidance and “arms” (in the form of distributed staff) to help with execution. We’ve found that the hybrid structure does the best job of ensuring development of long-term change management capabilities.
Organizational transformations are complex by their nature. Once they get going and start affecting people and processes, there is never a moment without some sort of hitch.
Effective change management functions are able to adjust the role they play as transformations advance from phase to phase, cultivate proven best-practice traits (including an employee-first approach), and know which parts of their change management organization to centralize and which parts to distribute.
There’s always going to be someone, at some point in a transformation, who is standing in the way. With the right change management elements, there will be fewer obstacles to overcome.
ABOUT BOSTON CONSULTING GROUP
Boston Consulting Group partners with leaders in business and society to tackle their most important challenges and capture their greatest opportunities. BCG was the pioneer in business strategy when it was founded in 1963. Today, we work closely with clients to embrace a transformational approach aimed at benefiting all stakeholders—empowering organizations to grow, build sustainable competitive advantage, and drive positive societal impact.
Our diverse, global teams bring deep industry and functional expertise and a range of perspectives that question the status quo and spark change. BCG delivers solutions through leading-edge management consulting, technology and design, and corporate and digital ventures. We work in a uniquely collaborative model across the firm and throughout all levels of the client organization, fueled by the goal of helping our clients thrive and enabling them to make the world a better place.
© Boston Consulting Group 2023. All rights reserved.
For information or permission to reprint, please contact BCG at firstname.lastname@example.org. To find the latest BCG content and register to receive e-alerts on this topic or others, please visit bcg.com. Follow Boston Consulting Group on Facebook and X (formerly Twitter).